ManagEnergy – Renewable Energy

Wind Turbine Vs Train




Affiliate Disclaimer

As an affiliate, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. We get commissions for purchases made through links on this website from Amazon and other third parties.

wind turbine vs train

As wind farms become more commonplace, there is an increasing need to transport large components–nacelles, towers and blades–safely and efficiently. Rail is the preferred mode of transport for such bulky items due to its versatility in this regard.

Railroads are three to four times more fuel efficient than trucks on a per ton mile basis, making them ideal for long hauls. Furthermore, as this video from Luling, Texas illustrates, railroads are even capable of carrying the bulky wind turbine blades used in modern wind generators.


Wind turbines are massive machines with long blades that must be transported. Shipping these pieces of machinery can be a hassle, particularly when other components must be shipped separately.

Wind energy companies must often transport parts around the country by rail, which can be expensive and time-consuming. Railroads collaborate with wind generator manufacturers and logistics partners to guarantee all equipment arrives undamaged.

NS Energy, which owns wind farms across the country, said it takes several months to plan and execute transport of the turbine’s major components. These include blades, towers and nacelles – typically transported on flatcars.

Prior to budgeting for transportation costs, you should carefully assess what needs to be moved. Additionally, determine which type of trailer will be necessary – if wind turbines consist of many individual pieces then a multi-axle trailer is recommended.

Once you’ve identified the wind turbine haulers who can accommodate oversized loads, research their capabilities. If the turbines are small and lightweight, a single trailer may suffice; however, for bigger and more sturdy machines, you will require either an 18-wheeler truck with wide-load trailer or multiple trailers.

One of the greatest difficulties when transporting these large turbines is navigating narrow tunnels. To reduce this issue, ultrasonic sensors can be used that detect approaching trains or tunnel walls and prompt the turbines to retract into their designated compartment within the train body.

Unfortunately, some tunnels are too narrow to safely accommodate the size of wind turbine blades, potentially leading to serious accidents. A video that went viral online showed a train colliding into a semi-truck carrying one in Luling, Texas on Sunday afternoon.

Though the crash was tragic, it serves as a poignant reminder of the potential hazards involved with transporting large, oversized loads via train. Furthermore, it demonstrates how smart technology and machine learning can make rail shipping safer through automation and smart technology.

Researchers have developed mathematical models that simulate the wind energy generation from turbines on moving trains. Unfortunately, most of these simulations fail to account for aerodynamic effects caused by increased drag force on train operation. To address this issue, a new approach for modeling wind turbines on trains was proposed.


Wind turbines are energy harvesters that capture wind energy by slowing its speed. If the turbine can extract more energy than it consumes, then it is more efficient. Efficiency depends on three factors: direction of wind flow, speed and angle of rotation.

A train, on the other hand, travels at fixed speeds. This causes it to produce large wind drafts that far exceed natural air velocity in its vicinity. These winds can be harnessed for energy generation by installing wind turbines near or on top of the train.

Wind turbines are able to produce much higher power output levels than their stationary counterparts due to being exposed to consistent high-velocity winds. This has prompted researchers to develop models with multiple wind turbines mounted on each train cart’s roof for increased output.

The additional weight of these turbines can cause significant drag, decreasing speed and stability for a train. Furthermore, their altered dimensions could have an effect on how smoothly it operates.

Wind shippers have often chosen to transport their products by rail in an effort to cut costs and minimize environmental impact. On a ton-mile basis, trains tend to be three to four times more fuel efficient than trucks on average – meaning a single ton of freight can be moved 444 miles with just one gallon of diesel, leaving behind significantly lower carbon footprint than trucks.

Trains are also a safer and more environmentally friendly shipping option since they move large dimensional loads at low speeds over long distances without creating much noise. Although some new wind turbine assemblies can be transported on trains, their size makes them difficult to fit into standard 89-ft railroad flat cars.

In addition to the above disadvantages, wind turbines on trains present several additional issues. For instance, their added aerodynamic drag can cause trains to move slower and make them more vulnerable to collisions with other vehicles or tunnel walls. Furthermore, excessive air pressure could damage them if not protected by protective casing or other reinforcements.


Wind turbines are an integral part of the renewable energy sector. They generate large amounts of electricity that can be used to power homes and businesses across America, thanks to tax credits and growing demand for green sources of power. As a result, this sector is experiencing unprecedented growth thanks to tax credits and rising demand for clean sources of energy.

Wind towers of 100kW to 1MW typically generate enough power for household needs and tend to be more cost-effective and straightforward to install than larger models.

However, larger projects necessitate larger and more powerful wind turbines for optimal power production. These larger towers typically generate 7.8 to 8.8MW of energy.

They create additional maintenance and safety issues, as well as being difficult to transport by truck – another reason why they’re typically shipped via train.

Railroads have become an increasingly important player in the transportation of wind turbine components. Many major parts of a wind turbine can be shipped via rail, such as blades, towers and nacelles.

These components are frequently placed on flatcars, which can then be loaded onto a freight train and transported to the manufacturer. There, specialized fixtures will be employed to secure the equipment to either rail car or truck so it travels safely and without damage.

Once the equipment has left the manufacturer, it will be transferred to a distribution center where it will remain until ready for delivery to its installation site. When components arrive at their final destination, they will be unloaded and prepared for assembly.

Railroading oversized components by train presents unique challenges, but they have found ways to overcome them. One solution lies in using new technology which enables them to monitor train car engines and detect problems early.

Another solution they are taking to address these problems is by combining sensors with machine learning in order to detect potential issues beforehand. This approach not only saves time and money, but it helps reduce breakdowns that might happen along the way.

Research into integrating wind turbines into trains is still in its early stages, but it shows promise if properly developed. Combining these technologies with an innovative train design approach that allows train carts to house the wind turbine apparatus could reduce drag force during acceleration and deceleration, producing more energy for the cart load.

Environmental Impact

The environmental benefits of wind turbines over trains vary based on the size and composition. A nacelle may weigh 56 tons while its blade can extend 50 meters in length.

Wind turbine components are extremely heavy, so they must be transported on special trains. To guarantee that these wind turbines clear every obstacle along their journey, meticulous planning and preparation must go into this transport plan.

Wind turbines prefer trains as the most environmentally-friendly transport option; they’re three to four times more fuel efficient per ton mile than trucks on average. That’s why many wind shippers utilize trains when transporting components long distances.

Global onshore wind energy production is predicted to reach 488,000 MW in 2040, an increase of 20% from 2020. To fully harness these renewable sources and minimize their environmental effects, technologies need to be developed that maximize their potential and minimize production impacts.

This paper conducts a global life cycle assessment (LCA) to assess the environmental impacts of OWE development. This LCA includes parameterized supply chains with high technology resolution and takes into account various scenarios for OWE growth in the near future.

We assessed the life cycle impacts of 12 different wind turbine systems, both onshore and offshore. To guarantee consistency across systems and background processes, we harmonized our life cycle inventories according to system boundaries and background processes. As a result, each system received an equivalent impact assessment.

To determine the environmental impacts per produced kWh, we employed an engineering-based model and empirical modeling. This allows us to distinguish pure turbine size effects from learning effects on LCA results for produced electricity.

The engineering-based model was able to derive scaling laws that fit both the expected pure size scale and empirical scaling laws found for hub height h and rotor diameter D (see Figure 1 in Supporting Information I). These two parameters can easily be measured, providing useful insight.

Scaling factors can be used to estimate impact categories based on turbine component mass M and total mass M, such as climate change, marine ecotoxicity and marine eutrophication. For all other impact categories however, scaling factors must be determined using either material mass M or energy for production and transport.

About the author

Latest posts